Your browser is unsupported

Please visit this URL to review a list of supported browsers.

Q1 2021 Options Review

Data Insights

Q3 2020 Options Review

October 13, 2020

While this summer came to a close, activity in the options markets continued to heat up. September 2020 set a new record for options industry average daily volume at 30.1 million contracts, which was driven by volatility, a downturn in equities markets after recent new highs and, perhaps, a boost from two high-profile stock splits. In addition, three days in September are now ranked among the top 10 multi-list volume days in options trading history. Nine of the top 10 multi-list options volume days occurred in the first three quarters of this year; just one trading day from 2011 remains on the top 10 list and could fall out before year end, given the Presidential election is just a few weeks away.

Top Volume Days

Rank Day Multi-List Equity & ETF Contracts
1 6/5/20 45,000,097
2 6/11/20 44,734,438
3 9/3/20 43,009,148
4 2/28/20 42,842,722
5 9/4/20 42,779,466
6 2/27/20 40,334,447
7 6/12/20 39,504,828
8 8/8/11 37,972,071
9 2/25/20 37,162,324
10 9/2/20 36,057,892

Market Quality

As we noted last quarter, options quoted spreads measured in basis points have returned to pre-pandemic levels. The displayed size at the best price has declined as spreads have tightened, with posted notional size 14% lower in Q3 than in Q2 (and notional size in Q2 was 32% lower than in Q1). On a monthly basis, however, posted notional size has improved each month in the quarter.

Quoted Spread (bps) and Posted Notional Size

High Profile Stock Splits

The third quarter saw two high-profile stock splits: shares of Apple (AAPL) split 4-for-1 on August 28, and Tesla (TSLA) split 5-for-1 on August 31. Following each split, AAPL and TSLA have experienced increased options volume. For AAPL, options volume is 3 times greater post-split than pre-split; TSLA’s volume is 2.6 times greater post-split. These stock splits had a significant impact on overall options volume, with post-split AAPL options accounting for 8.3% of multi-list volume, up from 3.3% pre-split, and post-split TSLA accounting for 4.8% of volume, up from 2.1% pre-split.

As expected, AAPL and TSLA market quality has improved in nominal terms. In general, a lower underlying stock price results in tighter nominal quote widths and a greater number of posted contracts to help maintain a similar level of pre-split posted market value. In notional terms, however, both AAPL and TSLA have wider quoted spreads measured in basis points and less posted size in market value terms following the splits. This could potentially be due to volatility and downward pressure on the tech sector in the month of September.

Spread($) and Size

Spread (bps) and Posted Notional Size

Unmatched Liquidity Index

In the second quarter, the NYSE introduced the Unmatched Liquidity Index to track the ratio of “unmatched volume” (non-auction and non-QCC volume) to “pre-matched volume” (auction and QCC volume). This index rose as volatility and market volumes increased into March, but then dropped from March to April when options trading floors closed. Retail trading increased dramatically as options volumes remained high during the closure period, suggesting that pre-matched orders were a key driver of market volume. However, record volume totals have not necessarily meant vastly expanded displayed liquidity across the market. The index continues to recover gradually and currently has a reading of 87.

Unmatched Liquidity Index

Volume Concentration

The volatility and recent stock splits have also impacted symbol concentration this year. Notably, SPY is no longer as dominant a driver of market volume as it has been in the past.

The first half of the year exhibited high SPY contribution to industry volume (19.3%), including the highest monthly SPY concentration on record in March (24.6%). In Q3, SPY fell to 14.2%, with one of the lowest SPY concentrations in the last 7 years in August (13.0%). Despite the low SPY contribution to industry volume, top 10 symbol concentration stayed flat, driven by an uptick in volume from other names in the top 10, such as AAPL, TSLA and several others.

SPY Volume Concentration

Top Symbols in 2020

2020
Symbol Rank % of Total
SPY 1 17.6%
AAPL 2 3.9%
QQQ 3 3.8%
TSLA 4 2.5%
IWM 5 2.1%
AMD 6 1.6%
MSFT 7 1.5%
SLV 8 1.5%
FB 9 1.2%
BAC 10 1.2%
2019
Rank % of Total
1 15.9%
3 3.0%
2 3.8%
7 1.5%
5 2.1%
6 1.7%
13 1.1%
28 0.7%
9 1.4%
8 1.5%

Conclusion

The options industry experienced record-setting volumes this year, and with the likelihood of more volatility on the horizon, we expect this trend to persist through year-end. The direction of quoted spreads and the Unmatched Liquidity Index show signs of recovery in market quality, and liquidity is less concentrated in a single underlying symbol (SPY). Nonetheless, market participants should remain prepared for a potential sharp reversal in these conditions, as political and macroeconomic risks remain.

Recent Articles


Closing Auction: Liquidity momentum around rebalances

August 25, 2022

The eight largest NYSE closing auctions have all occurred since June 2020, driven by growth in index rebalance events. We’ve previously studied the market impact of large auction orders and more recently highlighted the significant additional liquidity opportunities at the close. With significant index rebalances on the horizon, we now focus on volume dynamics in the days before and after large index rebalances, finding additional liquidity available in the market.

Read More

Closing Auction: Internalization effect throughout imbalance period

November 17, 2022

The NYSE Closing Auction accounts for 7.3% of total consolidated average daily trading volume in NYSE-listed securities, and over 10% in NYSE-listed securities that are in the S&P 500 Index. In addition to this unique, immense aggregation of liquidity in a single trade, broker-dealers fill some client on-close orders off the exchange prior to the closing auction and then use the closing price after the auction has occurred to complete the transaction

Read more

It’s Academic: NYSE-listed Stocks Receive Superior Market Quality

September 20, 2022

Comparing listing market quality across a large number of stocks is best achieved by using a matched sample, using key firm characteristics, such as sector, market cap, price and volume. Our analysis found that NYSE-listed stocks achieve tighter spreads, lower volatility and more accurate open and close auctions than their matched Nasdaq stocks, often by a significant margin.

Read More

Closing Auction: Liquidity momentum around rebalances

August 25, 2022

The eight largest NYSE closing auctions have all occurred since June 2020, driven by growth in index rebalance events. We’ve previously studied the market impact of large auction orders and more recently highlighted the significant additional liquidity opportunities at the close. With significant index rebalances on the horizon, we now focus on volume dynamics in the days before and after large index rebalances, finding additional liquidity available in the market.

Read More

Closing Auction: Internalization effect throughout imbalance period

November 17, 2022

The NYSE Closing Auction accounts for 7.3% of total consolidated average daily trading volume in NYSE-listed securities, and over 10% in NYSE-listed securities that are in the S&P 500 Index. In addition to this unique, immense aggregation of liquidity in a single trade, broker-dealers fill some client on-close orders off the exchange prior to the closing auction and then use the closing price after the auction has occurred to complete the transaction

Read more